8/10 Good
Paul D., London
26 Nov 2019
Liked: Cleanliness, check-in, communication, location, listing accuracy
Pleasant house in quiet location
Carried Away is one of 4 properties at the far end of Pigeon Cay, which is a nice, secluded part of the island. The house has lovely sunset views and has all the basics you need in a home, including aircon which is a godsend on hot days! Screened off porch allows for relatively bug free dining although you will still need bug spray, especially around sunset/twiglight as the no-seeums were out in force during our November stay. Debbie is extremely friendly and helpful and always on hand should you need anything or have question. The rooms are comfortable and the kayak was really helpful as it allowed us to paddle up to the main part of Pigeon Cay (we weren't brave enough to clamber the rocks to walk to it!). The island itself is beautiful and, for us, thankfully tourist lite. We were able to get all the groceries we needed on the island (New Bight has a couple of good stores, as well as 700 Wines, a great store for wine, spirits and beer). We ate out at Shanna Cove, Fernandez bay (both low key but very nice resorts) and Hidden Gems in New Bight, would recommend all three. I'd recommend car hire to go exploring, although you could probably do the island in two days, leaving plenty of time to relax on the beach and at the house. If you're looking for high-end, chi-chi resorts/villas then Cat Island probably isn't for you, however if you want relaxed island charm at its best then i'd definitely give the island a visit. Carried Away is a pleasant house, Maria was on hand with lots of advice on where to go, how to hire cars, getting to the island etc and the check-in with Debbie was very friendly and efficient. Would recommend both the house and the island.
Paul D.
Stayed 10 nights in Nov 2019